Economy: Apparently like... Jenga!

Since the very beginning of the debt crisis in Europe and the subsequent government spending cuts implemented, everyone- at least from my shallow academic entourage- was arguing, if not shouting, for the vicious circle of austerity. Shortly, beginning from a high debt-to-GDP ratio, public spending cuts affect more intensively the GDP than they do to the deficit and hence more cuts are required (the decrease of the denominator is larger that the one of the numerator) but at the same time GDP has already decreased more steeply. If you wish to argue for the opposite do not even dare; I am living in the center of this vicious circle. Currently, troika is coming back to Greece and from what I read they intend to respond to government revenues shortfall by more cuts...

 In other words, they remove another wooden block from the disposable income and they place it on top. That is exactly what happens in Greece over the last 3 years! Eventually, we will run out of wooden blocks and the game will be over when the tower collapses. If you ask  me what the alternative is, I would immediately answer you- I admit without second thoughts- that instead of the continuous shortsighted cuts a structural reform of the government consumption  along with patience and not necessarily more funding would be the appropriate tool combination and I am convinced that we would already had enjoyed the fruits of our efforts. I expect this vicious circle to begin in Cyprus.

 Let us take Jenga as an example of reality, once more. Imagine now that the economy of the Eurozone is a tower formed by the national income of its members (the wooden blocks). What would happen if we keep removing one block after another? Sooner or later the tower will collapse! With the US straggling to return to a forceful growth and the GDP of the EMU member-states attenuating more and more there will be no-one left to purchase the services and the goods produced by the strongest economies. Inevitably, all members will experience depression succeeded by the luck of funds necessary to guarantee the other members' debt. We have been digging our our own grave over the last couple of years...

 It is an identity equation: GDP equals consumption plus investment plus government spending plus current accounts balance. Κομίζω γλαῦκα ἐς Αθήνας*?

If you wish to expand Jenga to fit to global economy you are welcome!

 *Κομίζω γλαῦκα ἐς Αθήνας (kommizo glafka es Athinas); ancient Greek, figuratively means "speeking of widely known things".

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The good, the bad and... the austeritist!

This post is an attempt to use my rather inexperienced and naive instinct in economics in order to respond to the allegations of the necessity of austerity and tight monetary policy. More specifically, I post  my reply to the arguments presented in "The Live arguments of austerity right now: A bestiary" by Mr. DeLong . Please, forgive me if I am wrong. The first group stresses the importance of tight monetary policy. "The Jeremy Stein argument" : Stein ignores the other element of GDP; the consumption. With lower interest rates households can more easily substitute future for current income. Secondly, risk premium is added to the risk-free rate both when the risk-free is 0% and when it is higher, e.g. 10%, and hence risky assets yield by definition higher returns regardless the level of the risk-free rate. Therefore, bank managers will always prefer more risky assets due to the higher returns they offer anyway. Thirdly, there is always the Basel Accord tha...
Read more

The myth of internal devaluation and of competitiveness after Grexit (also in Greek)

Perhaps, I am seeing things the wrong way, but here is my thought: Following the 5th review of the IMF  and Athanasoglou (2011, Chart4, p.11)  on "The role of product variety and  quality and of domestic supply in foreign trade"  it is more than obvious that Greek firms are the largest importers. That is to say, Greece imports, heavily, factors of production other than labor. So, if Greece's non-labor production factors come from abroad, their prices are, also, set abroad... Therefore, the Greek firms may find it rather difficult to reduce their costs - no matter how labor cost might (?) be reduced - since the non-labor costs are set abroad. With firms finding difficult to reduce their costs, they will, subsequently, find it difficult to reduce their prices. This is a reason why prices did not deflate as wages did, so far, and why the the trade balance ameliorated mostly by the reduction of imports following the contraction of income and economic ...
Read more

The economics of the "success story"

There is something I need to admit... I am sick of the so called "success story" and the naive- false and deceitful, if you are as malicious as I am- declarations of the opposition. Here are the facts: During 2008, Greece produced goods and services of 240 bn euros. During the period April 2012- March 2013 GDP in current prices was 190 bn euros ( EL.STAT .). By the end of March 2013 the debt of the Central Government was 309 bn euros ( Ministry of Finance ), i.e. 161% of Greek GDP.  Additional measures need to be taken in order to make sure that the Central Government debt will be less than 110% of GDP by 2022. The most auspicious scenario is that the current taxation will remain unchanged for at least until 2015 with the hope that recession will deescalate. Anyway, I do not really believe that there is any more space left for heavier taxation. On the other hand, we are still missing the big picture: while oscillation between anemic growth and periods of recessions ten...
Read more